For decades, we’ve been told that depression is caused by a chemical imbalance in the brain – specifically, low serotonin. This idea has shaped how society understands mental health and how millions of prescriptions are written each year.
But what if this narrative is incomplete – or even untrue?
💊 The Serotonin Theory: A Story Under Scrutiny
The serotonin theory of depression emerged in the 1960s and became widely popular in the 1990s when pharmaceutical companies began marketing SSRIs (Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors) like Prozac.
These drugs were designed to increase serotonin levels in the brain. The public messaging was simple:
✅ Depression = low serotonin
✅ SSRIs fix serotonin = feel better
✅ SSRIs fix serotonin = feel better
This story made sense. It was easy to understand, easy to market, and comforting to think depression had a clear biological cause.
🔬 What Does the Latest Science Say?
A landmark systematic umbrella review published in Molecular Psychiatry titled “The serotonin theory of depression: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence” analyzed decades of research involving tens of thousands of people.
Here’s what scientists found:
- No consistent evidence that people with depression have lower serotonin levels than healthy individuals.
- Studies lowering serotonin artificially in healthy volunteers did not induce depression.
- The serotonin theory lacks scientific grounding despite its public popularity.
Professor Joanna Moncrieff, lead author of the study and professor of psychiatry at University College London, explained:
“Many people take antidepressants because they have been led to believe their depression has a biochemical cause, but this new research suggests this belief is not grounded in evidence…. It is high time to inform the public that this belief is not grounded in science.”
⚠️ What Does This Mean for Antidepressants?
This doesn’t mean SSRIs never help people. For some, they provide temporary relief. But how they actually work remains unclear. Many studies suggest their benefits may come largely from the placebo effect and induced hope, rather than correcting a chemical imbalance.
Moreover, SSRIs:
- Alter normal brain chemistry
- Often blunt both negative and positive emotions
- Can create dependency without addressing root causes
🌌 If Not Chemical Imbalance, Then What?
Modern neuroscience and trauma studies suggest depression is less about a defective brain and more about:
🌿 Nervous system dysregulation – stuck in chronic fight, flight, or freeze
🌿 Trauma imprints – unresolved emotional pain from the past
🌿 Disconnection from meaning, purpose, and authentic belonging
🌿 Lifestyle and environmental stressors – sleep, food, nature, community
🌿 Trauma imprints – unresolved emotional pain from the past
🌿 Disconnection from meaning, purpose, and authentic belonging
🌿 Lifestyle and environmental stressors – sleep, food, nature, community
These factors change brain chemistry and structure over time, but they are rooted in human experience, not just biology.
💡 Moving Forward: A More Holistic View
Depression is not a simple serotonin problem. It is a complex psycho-somatic-spiritual condition. Healing requires:
✅ Nervous system regulation (breathwork, somatic therapy, yoga)
✅ Trauma healing and emotional processing
✅ Supportive relationships and safe community
✅ Nutrition, sleep, nature, and mindful living
✅ Rediscovering purpose and meaning
✅ Trauma healing and emotional processing
✅ Supportive relationships and safe community
✅ Nutrition, sleep, nature, and mindful living
✅ Rediscovering purpose and meaning
🙏 Final Thoughts
We are not broken chemical machines needing fixing. We are living, feeling, interconnected beings needing understanding, safety, and care.
When the root cause is nervous system dysregulation, trauma, or existential disconnection, medications alone will never heal us. They may suppress symptoms, but true healing comes from coming home to ourselves, with compassion and courage.
💭 What are your thoughts on the serotonin theory of depression? Have you experienced depression as a purely biological or a holistic issue?
Let me know if you wish to create a course module or social series explaining this science in accessible, empowering ways for your audience this week.
0 Comments